Difference between revisions of "AoPS Wiki:AoPS-Mathlinks Rules and Tips"

(See also: category)
 
(4 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
== MATHEMATICAL DISCUSSION ==
+
== Mathematical Discussion ==
  
MathLinks is a community for discussing mathematical problems on various levels. You can share problems with others, solve others' problems, create your own problems and post them, and more.
+
The Art of Problem Solving Forum & MathLinks are a shared community for discussing mathematical problems on various levels. You can share problems with others, solve others' problems, create your own problems and post them, and more.
  
 
== Posting problems on AoPS/MathLinks ==
 
== Posting problems on AoPS/MathLinks ==
Line 21: Line 21:
 
If you have a problem, you have to choose the right forum according to its level:
 
If you have a problem, you have to choose the right forum according to its level:
  
*[http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/index.php?f=149 Getting Started] is for ''insert stuff here, but please make it understandable to non-Americans.''
+
*[http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/index.php?f=149 High School Basics] is for problems that would be considered part of the standard U.S. high school curriculum.  This generally means algebra and geometry.  Very easy combinatorics or number theory problems would also be appropriate for this forum.  Problems in this forum should be at the SAT or easy AMC 10/12 level.  Problems in this forum should usually not require complicated proofs.
*[http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/index.php?f=150 Intermediate Topics] is for ''insert stuff here, but please make it understandable to non-Americans.''
+
*[http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/index.php?f=150 Intermediate Topics] is for problems that are harder than "basic", but not yet approaching the olympiad level.  Some examples are harder AMC 10/12 problems or easier AIME problems.  Generally these will be problems that do not require complicated proofs.
*[http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/index.php?f=151 Pre-Olympiad] is for problems slightly under the olympiad level and for very easy olympiad problems.
+
*[http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/index.php?f=151 Pre-Olympiad] is for problems slightly under the olympiad level and for very easy olympiad problems.  Many problems at this level will require proofs.
*[http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/index.php?f=217 Olympiad Section] is for olympiad-level problems.  
+
*[http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/index.php?f=217 Olympiad Section] is for olympiad-level problems.  
**Olympiad-level means the level of [http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/resources.php?c=1&cid=16 the IMO], of [http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/resources.php?c=1&cid=17 IMO shortlists], of [http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/resources.php?c=182&cid=27 the USAMO] or [http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/resources.php?c=1&cid=60 the Baltic Way mathematical competition].
+
**Olympiad-level means the level of [http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/resources.php?c=1&cid=16 the IMO], of [http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/resources.php?c=1&cid=17 IMO shortlists], of [http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/resources.php?c=182&cid=27 the USAMO] or [http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/resources.php?c=1&cid=60 the Baltic Way mathematical competition].
*[http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/index.php?f=218 College Playground] is a special forum for problems that require preknowledge which is usually not given in schools - for instance, [[linear algebra]], [[calculus]], [[topology]].
+
*[http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/index.php?f=218 College Playground] is a special forum for problems that require knowledge that is usually not given in schools - for instance, [[linear algebra]], [[calculus]], [[topology]].
  
The [http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/index.php?f=217 Olympiad Section] is subdivided into subforums:  
+
The [http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/index.php?f=217 Olympiad Section] is subdivided into subforums:  
* [http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/index.php?f=3 Algebra]  
+
* [http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/index.php?f=3 Algebra]  
* [http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/index.php?f=5 Combinatorics]  
+
* [http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/index.php?f=5 Combinatorics]  
* [http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/index.php?f=4 Geometry]
+
* [http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/index.php?f=4 Geometry]
* [http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/index.php?f=32 Inequalities]
+
* [http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/index.php?f=32 Inequalities]
* [http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/index.php?f=6 Number Theory]  
+
* [http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/index.php?f=6 Number Theory]  
  
 
Decide which topic your problem belongs to, and post it into the respective subforum.
 
Decide which topic your problem belongs to, and post it into the respective subforum.
Line 39: Line 39:
 
Each of these subforums is subdivided into subsubforums:
 
Each of these subforums is subdivided into subsubforums:
  
* <u>Unsolved Problems:</u> Post your problem here if you don't know its solution and you are searching for it, but you know there is a solution (e. g. because the problem was given at an olympiad).
+
* <u>Unsolved Problems:</u> Post your problem here if you don't know its solution and you are searching for it, but you know there is a solution (e.g. because the problem was given at an olympiad).
 
* <u>Proposed & Own Problems:</u> Post your problem here if you know the solution and you want to share the problem with others.
 
* <u>Proposed & Own Problems:</u> Post your problem here if you know the solution and you want to share the problem with others.
* <u>Open Questions:</u> Post your problem here if it is a conjecture, i. e. you don't have its solution and you don't even know whether it has ever been solved.
+
* <u>Open Questions:</u> Post your problem here if it is a conjecture, i.e. you don't have its solution and you don't even know whether it has ever been solved.
 
* <u>Solved Problems:</u> This is the archive for former "Unsolved" problems which were then solved. Don't post new problems here, it's an archive!
 
* <u>Solved Problems:</u> This is the archive for former "Unsolved" problems which were then solved. Don't post new problems here, it's an archive!
 
* <u>Theorems and Formulas:</u> This is for important and useful theorems.
 
* <u>Theorems and Formulas:</u> This is for important and useful theorems.
Line 47: Line 47:
 
=== How to post ===
 
=== How to post ===
  
All questions and answers should be:
+
All posts should:
* correct: no typos, no errors, check at least twice what you post.
+
* be correct: strive for no typos and errors, and double-check your message before you post it.  If you find a typo after posting, please edit your message to correct it.
* readable: use LaTeX (see below), don't quote whole pages just to make a one-line answer.
+
* be readable: use [[LaTeX]] (see below) on your mathematical statements.  Write in complete sentences.  
* it's interesting and/or helpful for someone: a reply that just contains "it's easy" or "I solved it" interests noone
+
* be interesting and/or helpful for someone: a reply that just contains "it's easy" or "I solved it" interests no one.  Every post should have some content.
* it's appropriate and ontopic: be nice, don't shout or insult, post only stuff that fits into the topic
+
* don't quote whole pages just to make a one-line answer.  You don't need to quote previous response(s) unless you are responding to a specific portion of someone's earlier post.
 +
* be appropriate and on-topic: be nice, don't shout or insult, and post only things that fit the topic.
 +
* always practice good [[netiquette]].
  
 
=== Posting solutions ===
 
=== Posting solutions ===
Line 57: Line 59:
 
Wherever you see a problem on the forum, you can post a solution to it if you want.
 
Wherever you see a problem on the forum, you can post a solution to it if you want.
  
The solution needs not be 100% detailed, but it must be understandable. Posts consisting only of words like "The problem is easy" or "Cauchy-Schwarz solves it" have no value and will be deleted.
+
The solution needs not be 100% detailed, but it must be understandable. Posts consisting only of words like "The problem is easy" or "Cauchy-Schwarz solves it" have no value and may be deleted.
 +
 
 +
Please post solutions at your level!  If you are an Olympiad-level student, do not post solutions in the "High School Basics" forum -- leave those problems for students at that level.  However, you may comment (politely, of course!) on other students' solutions, and/or provide hints if the students seem stuck.
  
 
=== Other cases of posting ===
 
=== Other cases of posting ===
  
You are not limited to posting and solving problems. You can write whatever you want, assumed that it is useful and relevant to the forum. For instance, you can generalize problems, point out mistakes in others' proofs, ask questions about others' solutions, simplify others' solutions etc.. But note that the mathematical sections of AoPS/MathLinks are for mathematical discussion only. For non-mathematical discussions, there is the [http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/index.php?f=138 Round Table], the [http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/index.php?f=139 Games & Fun Factory] and some more. Non-mathematical discussions in mathematical sections of AoPS/MathLinks can be considered offtopic and removed.
+
You are not limited to posting and solving problems. You can write whatever you want, assumed that it is useful and relevant to the forum. For instance, you can generalize problems, point out mistakes in others' proofs, ask questions about others' solutions, simplify others' solutions, and so on.   But please note that the mathematical sections of AoPS/MathLinks are for mathematical discussion only. For non-mathematical discussions, there are the [http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/index.php?f=138 Round Table], the [http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/index.php?f=139 Games & Fun Factory] and some more. Non-mathematical discussions in mathematical sections of AoPS/MathLinks can be considered offtopic and removed.
  
 
=== Running competitions and homework ===
 
=== Running competitions and homework ===
  
This is obvious, but let's strike it here too: Don't post problems from '''running''' homework competitions! You are supposed to solve them on your own, so making others solve them for you is cheating!
+
This may be obvious, but: Don't post problems from '''running''' homework competitions! You are supposed to solve them on your own, so making others solve them for you is cheating!
  
 
If you post school or university homework problems, please indicate that your problems are homework. In most cases, you will get no complete solutions, but hints and other help.
 
If you post school or university homework problems, please indicate that your problems are homework. In most cases, you will get no complete solutions, but hints and other help.
Line 71: Line 75:
 
=== Using LaTeX ===
 
=== Using LaTeX ===
  
[[LaTeX]] makes it possible to include formulas in your posts. For instance, by writing <pre><nowiki>$a^2 + a^3b$</nowiki></pre> you get <math>a^{2}+a^{3}b</math>, and by writing <pre><nowiki>$\frac{a}{b} + 2! = 3^{10}$</nowiki></pre> you get <math>\frac{a}{b}+2! = 3^{10}</math>. Learning LaTeX is very easy by [http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/viewtopic.php?t=5261 this short tutorial] and by testing it out on the forum. Testing can be done in the [http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/index.php?f=224 Test Forum].
+
[[LaTeX]] makes it possible to include formulas in your posts. For instance, by writing <pre><nowiki>$a^2 + a^3b$</nowiki></pre> you get <math>a^{2}+a^{3}b</math>, and by writing <pre><nowiki>$\frac{a}{b} + 2! = 3^{10}$</nowiki></pre> you get <math>\frac{a}{b}+2! = 3^{10}</math>. Learning LaTeX is very easy by [http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/viewtopic.php?t=5261 this short tutorial] and by testing it out on the forum. Testing can be done in the [http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/index.php?f=224 Test Forum].
  
 
=== Searching on the forum ===
 
=== Searching on the forum ===
Line 77: Line 81:
 
Before you post a new problem, you should ask yourself whether this problem has already been discussed on AoPS/MathLinks. You can find this out using two functions of the forum:
 
Before you post a new problem, you should ask yourself whether this problem has already been discussed on AoPS/MathLinks. You can find this out using two functions of the forum:
  
[http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/search.php The Search function] helps you find topics in the forum by some keywords. For instance, if your problem is from the USAMO 2002, you can type "USAMO 2002" into the search field. If your problem is about a triangle, its incircle and some altitudes, you can try typing "triangle incircle altitude*" into the search field (the * in "altitude*" is there to find both "altitude" and "altitudes"). You can also restrict the search to some subforums if necessary, so if you look for a Number Theory problem, try restricting the search to the Number Theory subforum if at first there were too many results.
+
[http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/search.php The Search function] helps you find topics in the forum by some keywords. For instance, if your problem is from the USAMO 2002, you can type "USAMO 2002" into the search field. If your problem is about a triangle, its incircle and some altitudes, you can try typing "triangle incircle altitude*" into the search field (the * in "altitude*" is there to find both "altitude" and "altitudes"). You can also restrict the search to some subforums if necessary, so if you look for a Number Theory problem, try restricting the search to the Number Theory subforum if at first there were too many results.
  
[http://www.mathlinks.ro/Forum/resources.php The Resources section] contains lists of problems of several olympiads. If you know what competition your problem is from, you can look up this competition in the Resources section. If you find your problem there, click on the problem number on the left of the page, and you get a thread with this problem.
+
[http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Forum/resources.php The Resources section] contains lists of problems of several olympiads. If you know what competition your problem is from, you can look up this competition in the Resources section. If you find your problem there, click on the problem number on the left of the page, and you get a thread with this problem.
  
 
You are not supposed to spend half an hour searching for your problem on AoPS/MathLinks, but it is helpful if you try it at least once, better twice.
 
You are not supposed to spend half an hour searching for your problem on AoPS/MathLinks, but it is helpful if you try it at least once, better twice.
 
=== Naming your topic ===
 
 
Topic naming
 
In creating a new topic, you have to write a name of it, under all others will see it before they will click on it and see your problem. It is better to write names like "prove concurrency", "a^4+b^4+c^4\geq a^3b+b^3c+c^3a", "a^2+b^2=20c^2", "f(xf(y))f(y)=yf(xy)" than the following ones: "hard geometry", "please help me!!", "what to do with this one?", "don't know how to solve it". Describe very briefly and concisely the problem.
 
  
 
== See also ==
 
== See also ==
 
* [[Main Page]]
 
* [[Main Page]]
  
[[Category:Tutorials]]
+
[[Category:AoPSWiki|AoPS-Mathlinks Rules and Tips]]

Latest revision as of 19:58, 11 December 2007

Mathematical Discussion

The Art of Problem Solving Forum & MathLinks are a shared community for discussing mathematical problems on various levels. You can share problems with others, solve others' problems, create your own problems and post them, and more.

Posting problems on AoPS/MathLinks

Posting problems

If you want to post a new problem, post it in a new topic. If you have several problems to post, post every problem in a new topic.

Discussing different problems in one topic leads to confusion.

Please double check your problem for mistakes. A simple typo in a formula can make a problem incomprehensible.

Please also give your topic a useful name. Names should describe something. It is better to write names like "prove concurrency in a right-angled triangle", "a^4+b^4+c^4\geq a^3b+b^3c+c^3a", "a^2+b^2=20c^2", "f(xf(y))f(y)=yf(xy)" than the following ones: "hard geometry", "please help me!!", "what to do with this one?", "don't know how to solve it".

Where to post

There are different forums to post problems in.

If you have a problem, you have to choose the right forum according to its level:

  • High School Basics is for problems that would be considered part of the standard U.S. high school curriculum. This generally means algebra and geometry. Very easy combinatorics or number theory problems would also be appropriate for this forum. Problems in this forum should be at the SAT or easy AMC 10/12 level. Problems in this forum should usually not require complicated proofs.
  • Intermediate Topics is for problems that are harder than "basic", but not yet approaching the olympiad level. Some examples are harder AMC 10/12 problems or easier AIME problems. Generally these will be problems that do not require complicated proofs.
  • Pre-Olympiad is for problems slightly under the olympiad level and for very easy olympiad problems. Many problems at this level will require proofs.
  • Olympiad Section is for olympiad-level problems.
  • College Playground is a special forum for problems that require knowledge that is usually not given in schools - for instance, linear algebra, calculus, topology.

The Olympiad Section is subdivided into subforums:

Decide which topic your problem belongs to, and post it into the respective subforum.

Each of these subforums is subdivided into subsubforums:

  • Unsolved Problems: Post your problem here if you don't know its solution and you are searching for it, but you know there is a solution (e.g. because the problem was given at an olympiad).
  • Proposed & Own Problems: Post your problem here if you know the solution and you want to share the problem with others.
  • Open Questions: Post your problem here if it is a conjecture, i.e. you don't have its solution and you don't even know whether it has ever been solved.
  • Solved Problems: This is the archive for former "Unsolved" problems which were then solved. Don't post new problems here, it's an archive!
  • Theorems and Formulas: This is for important and useful theorems.

How to post

All posts should:

  • be correct: strive for no typos and errors, and double-check your message before you post it. If you find a typo after posting, please edit your message to correct it.
  • be readable: use LaTeX (see below) on your mathematical statements. Write in complete sentences.
  • be interesting and/or helpful for someone: a reply that just contains "it's easy" or "I solved it" interests no one. Every post should have some content.
  • don't quote whole pages just to make a one-line answer. You don't need to quote previous response(s) unless you are responding to a specific portion of someone's earlier post.
  • be appropriate and on-topic: be nice, don't shout or insult, and post only things that fit the topic.
  • always practice good netiquette.

Posting solutions

Wherever you see a problem on the forum, you can post a solution to it if you want.

The solution needs not be 100% detailed, but it must be understandable. Posts consisting only of words like "The problem is easy" or "Cauchy-Schwarz solves it" have no value and may be deleted.

Please post solutions at your level! If you are an Olympiad-level student, do not post solutions in the "High School Basics" forum -- leave those problems for students at that level. However, you may comment (politely, of course!) on other students' solutions, and/or provide hints if the students seem stuck.

Other cases of posting

You are not limited to posting and solving problems. You can write whatever you want, assumed that it is useful and relevant to the forum. For instance, you can generalize problems, point out mistakes in others' proofs, ask questions about others' solutions, simplify others' solutions, and so on. But please note that the mathematical sections of AoPS/MathLinks are for mathematical discussion only. For non-mathematical discussions, there are the Round Table, the Games & Fun Factory and some more. Non-mathematical discussions in mathematical sections of AoPS/MathLinks can be considered offtopic and removed.

Running competitions and homework

This may be obvious, but: Don't post problems from running homework competitions! You are supposed to solve them on your own, so making others solve them for you is cheating!

If you post school or university homework problems, please indicate that your problems are homework. In most cases, you will get no complete solutions, but hints and other help.

Using LaTeX

LaTeX makes it possible to include formulas in your posts. For instance, by writing

$a^2 + a^3b$

you get $a^{2}+a^{3}b$, and by writing

$\frac{a}{b} + 2! = 3^{10}$

you get $\frac{a}{b}+2! = 3^{10}$. Learning LaTeX is very easy by this short tutorial and by testing it out on the forum. Testing can be done in the Test Forum.

Searching on the forum

Before you post a new problem, you should ask yourself whether this problem has already been discussed on AoPS/MathLinks. You can find this out using two functions of the forum:

The Search function helps you find topics in the forum by some keywords. For instance, if your problem is from the USAMO 2002, you can type "USAMO 2002" into the search field. If your problem is about a triangle, its incircle and some altitudes, you can try typing "triangle incircle altitude*" into the search field (the * in "altitude*" is there to find both "altitude" and "altitudes"). You can also restrict the search to some subforums if necessary, so if you look for a Number Theory problem, try restricting the search to the Number Theory subforum if at first there were too many results.

The Resources section contains lists of problems of several olympiads. If you know what competition your problem is from, you can look up this competition in the Resources section. If you find your problem there, click on the problem number on the left of the page, and you get a thread with this problem.

You are not supposed to spend half an hour searching for your problem on AoPS/MathLinks, but it is helpful if you try it at least once, better twice.

See also

Invalid username
Login to AoPS