Three Distances Problem.
by luimichael, Oct 31, 2007, 1:24 AM
Given a square ABCD with unknown side.
A point P in the plane of ABCD has distances a, b, c from the corners A, B and D respectively.
Determine the size of the square in terms of a, b and c.
Solution:
Method 1
By Trigonometry
Click to reveal hidden text
Method 2
Application of Coordinates GeometryClick to reveal hidden text
*******************************************************************************
Method 3
Rotation of Figure
Assume the case with P inside ABCD.
Rotate triangle PAB around the corner A through 90 degrees in the counter-clockwise sense.
Then P will be rotated to a new point, say Q, with AQ = a and DQ = b.
Calculating the area of APDQ in two different ways:
First: Sum of areas of triangles APQ and PDQ by Heron's Formula in Expanded form.
Second: Area of quadrilateral APDQ by Bretschneider's Formula.
A point P in the plane of ABCD has distances a, b, c from the corners A, B and D respectively.
Determine the size of the square in terms of a, b and c.
Solution:
Method 1
By Trigonometry
Click to reveal hidden text
Under the assumption that P is lying inside ABCD.
Let u be the length of a side of the square and denote the angle PAB by
.
By Cosine Formula, we have
(1)
and
(2)
From (2), we have
-
(3)
With the Trigonometric Identity
, plugging in (1) and (3):
(*)
Then,
-
(**)
, which is a simple quadratic equation in
.
Therefore,
can be found exactly and hence u can be evaluated exactly too.
Question:
What happens if P is outside the square ABCD ?
Does (*) hold in this case?
The answer is affirmative.
********************************************************************************Let u be the length of a side of the square and denote the angle PAB by

By Cosine Formula, we have

(1)
and

(2)
From (2), we have

(3)
With the Trigonometric Identity


(*)
Then,

(**)
, which is a simple quadratic equation in

Therefore,

Question:
What happens if P is outside the square ABCD ?
Does (*) hold in this case?
The answer is affirmative.
Method 2
Application of Coordinates GeometryClick to reveal hidden text
Regard A as the origin, AB as the x-axis and AD as the y-axis.
P can be regarded as the intersection point of the three circles below:
-
(4)
-
(5)
-
(6)
From (5):
(7)
From (6):
-
(8)
(4) - (7):
(4) - (8):
.
Substitute (9) and (10) into (4), then re-arrange terms we again obtain (**) in Method 1.
P can be regarded as the intersection point of the three circles below:

(4)

(5)

(6)
From (5):

(7)
From (6):

(8)
(4) - (7):

(4) - (8):

Substitute (9) and (10) into (4), then re-arrange terms we again obtain (**) in Method 1.
*******************************************************************************
Method 3
Rotation of Figure
Assume the case with P inside ABCD.
Rotate triangle PAB around the corner A through 90 degrees in the counter-clockwise sense.
Then P will be rotated to a new point, say Q, with AQ = a and DQ = b.
Calculating the area of APDQ in two different ways:
First: Sum of areas of triangles APQ and PDQ by Heron's Formula in Expanded form.
Second: Area of quadrilateral APDQ by Bretschneider's Formula.