Difference between revisions of "2014 USAJMO Problems/Problem 2"

Latest revision as of 18:40, 28 February 2023

Problem

Let $\triangle{ABC}$ be a non-equilateral, acute triangle with $\angle A=60^{\circ}$ , and let $O$ and $H$ denote the circumcenter and orthocenter of $\triangle{ABC}$ , respectively.

(a) Prove that line $OH$ intersects both segments $AB$ and $AC$ .

(b) Line $OH$ intersects segments $AB$ and $AC$ at $P$ and $Q$ , respectively. Denote by $s$ and $t$ the respective areas of triangle $APQ$ and quadrilateral $BPQC$ . Determine the range of possible values for $s/t$ .

Solution

$[asy] import olympiad; unitsize(1inch); pair A,B,C,O,H,P,Q,i1,i2,i3,i4; //define dots A=3*dir(50); B=(0,0); C=right*2.76481496; O=circumcenter(A,B,C); H=orthocenter(A,B,C); i1=2*O-H; i2=2*i1-O; i3=2*H-O; i4=2*i3-H; //These points are for extending PQ. DO NOT DELETE! P=intersectionpoint(i2--i4,A--B); Q=intersectionpoint(i2--i4,A--C); //draw dot(P); dot(Q); draw(P--Q); dot(A); dot(B); dot(C); dot(O); dot(H); draw(A--B--C--cycle); //label label("$A$",A,N); label("$B$",B,SW); label("$C$",C,SE); label("$P$",P,NW); label("$Q$",Q,NE); label("$O$",O,N); label("$H$",H,N); //change O and H label positions if interfering with other lines to be added //further editing: ABCPQOH are the dots to be further used. i1,i2,i3,i4 are for drawing assistance and are not to be used [/asy]$

Lemma: $H$ is the reflection of $O$ over the angle bisector of $\angle BAC$ (henceforth 'the' reflection)

Proof: Let $H'$ be the reflection of $O$ , and let $B'$ be the reflection of $B$ .

Then reflection takes $\angle ABH'$ to $\angle AB'O$ .

$\Delta ABB'$ is equilateral, and $O$ lies on the perpendicular bisector of $\overline{AB}$

It's well known that $O$ lies strictly inside $\Delta ABC$ (since it's acute), meaning that $\angle ABH' = \angle AB'O = 30^{\circ},$ from which it follows that $\overline{BH'} \perp \overline{AC}$ . Similarly, $\overline{CH'} \perp \overline{AB}$ . Since $H'$ lies on two altitudes, $H'$ is the orthocenter, as desired.

End Lemma

So $\overline{OH}$ is perpendicular to the angle bisector of $\angle OAH$ , which is the same line as the angle bisector of $\angle BAC$ , meaning that $\Delta APQ$ is equilateral.

Let its side length be $s$ , and let $PH=t$ , where $0 < t < s, t \neq s/2$ because $O$ lies strictly within $\angle BAC$ , as must $H$ , the reflection of $O$ . Also, it's easy to show that if $O=H$ in a general triangle, it's equilateral, and we know $\Delta ABC$ is not equilateral. Hence H is not on the bisector of $\angle BAC \implies t \neq s/2$ . Let $\overrightarrow{BH}$ intersect $\overline{AC}$ at $P_B$ .

Since $\Delta HP_BQ$ and $BP_BA$ are 30-60-90 triangles, $AB=2AP_B=2(s-QP_B)=2(s-HQ/2)=2s-HQ=2s-(s-t)=s+t$

Similarly, $AC=2s-t$

The ratio $\frac{[APQ]}{[ABC]-[APQ]}$ is $\frac{AP \cdot AQ}{AB \cdot AC - AP \cdot AQ} = \frac{s^2}{(s+t)(2s-t)-s^2}$ The denominator equals $(1.5s)^2-(.5s-t)^2-s^2$ where $.5s-t$ can equal any value in $(-.5s, .5s)$ except $0$ . Therefore, the denominator can equal any value in $(s^2, 5s^2/4)$ , and the ratio is any value in $\boxed{\left(\frac{4}{5},1\right)}.$

Note: It's easy to show that for any point $H$ on $\overline{PQ}$ except the midpoint, Points B and C can be validly defined to make an acute, non-equilateral triangle.

Solution 2

Let $J$ be the farthest point on the circumcircle of $\triangle{ABC}$ from line $BC$ . Lemma: Line $AJ$ ||Line $OH$ Proof: Set $b=-\dfrac{1}{2}+i\dfrac{\sqrt{3}}{2}$ and $c=-\dfrac{1}{2}-i\dfrac{\sqrt{3}}{2}$ , and $a$ on the unit circle. It is well known that $o=0$ and $h=a+b+c$ , so we have $h-o=a+b+c=a-1=a-j$ , so $\dfrac{a-j}{h-o}$ is real and thus the 2 lines are parallel.

WLOG let $A$ be in the first quadrant. Clearly by the above lemma $OH$ must intersect line $BC$ closer to $B$ than to $C$ . Intersect $AJ$ and $BC$ at $D$ and $OH$ and $BC$ at $E$ . We clearly have $0 < \dfrac{\overarc{JC}-\overarc{AB}}{2} = \dfrac{120-\overarc{AC}}{2} = \angle{ADB} = \angle{OEC} < 30 = \angle{OBC}$ , $OH$ must intersect $AB$ . We also have, letting the intersection of line $OH$ and line $AC$ be $Q$ , and letting intersection of $OH$ and $AB$ be $P$ , $\angle{OQA} = \angle{JAB} = \dfrac{\overarc{JB}}{2} = 60$ . Since $\angle{OCA}=\angle{BCA}-\angle{BCO} < 90-30 =\angle{OQA}$ , and $\angle{OQC} = 120>\angle{OAC}$ , $OH$ also intersects $AC$ . We have $\angle{OPA}=\angle{PAJ}=60$ , so $\triangle{APQ}$ is equilateral. Letting $AJ=2x$ , and letting the foot of the perpendicular from $O$ to $AJ$ be $L$ , we have $OL=\sqrt{1-x^{2}}$ , and since $OL$ is an altitude of $\triangle{APQ}$ , we have $[APQ]=\dfrac{OL^{2}\sqrt{3}}{3} = \dfrac{\sqrt{3}(1-x^{2})}{3}$ . Letting the foot of the perpendicular from $A$ to $OJ$ be $K$ , we have $\triangle{JKA}\sim \triangle{JLO}$ by AA with ratio $\dfrac{JA}{JO} = 2x$ . Therefore, $JK = 2x(JL) = 2x^{2}$ . Letting $D$ be the foot of the altitude from $J$ to $BC$ , we have $KD=JD-JK=\dfrac{3}{2}-2x^{2}$ , since $re(B)=re(C) \implies JD=re(j)-(-\dfrac{1}{2})=\dfrac{3}{2}$ . Thus, since $BC=\sqrt{3}$ we have $[ABC]=\dfrac{(\dfrac{3}{2}-2x^{2})(\sqrt{3})}{2} = \dfrac{(3-4x^{2})(\sqrt{3})}{2}$ , so $[PQCB]=[ABC]-[APQ]=\dfrac{(5-8x^{2})(\sqrt{3})}{12}$ , so $\dfrac{[APQ]}{[PQCB]} = \dfrac{4-4x^{2}}{5-8x^{2}} = \dfrac{1}{2}+\dfrac{3}{10-16x^{2}}$ . We have $x=\sin(\dfrac{JOA}{2})$ , with $0<120-2\angle{ACB}=\angle{JOA}<60$ , so $x$ can be anything in the interval $(0, \dfrac{1}{2})$ . Therefore, the desired range is $(\dfrac{4}{5}, 1)$ .

Solution by Shaddoll

2014 USAJMO (Problems • Resources)
Preceded by Problem 1	Followed by Problem 3
1 • 2 • 3 • 4 • 5 • 6
All USAJMO Problems and Solutions

Page

Toolbox

Search

Difference between revisions of "2014 USAJMO Problems/Problem 2"

Latest revision as of 18:40, 28 February 2023

Contents

Problem

Solution

Solution 2

See Also

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
 ==Problem==
-Let <math>\triangle{ABC}</math> be a non-equilateral, acute triangle with <math>\angle A=60\textdegrees</math>, and let <math>O</math> and <math>H</math> denote the circumcenter and orthocenter of <math>\triangle{ABC}</math>, respectively.
+Let <math>\triangle{ABC}</math> be a non-equilateral, acute triangle with <math>\angle A=60^{\circ}</math>, and let <math>O</math> and <math>H</math> denote the circumcenter and orthocenter of <math>\triangle{ABC}</math>, respectively.
 (a) Prove that line <math>OH</math> intersects both segments <math>AB</math> and <math>AC</math>.
 (b) Line <math>OH</math> intersects segments <math>AB</math> and <math>AC</math> at <math>P</math> and <math>Q</math>, respectively. Denote by <math>s</math> and <math>t</math> the respective areas of triangle <math>APQ</math> and quadrilateral <math>BPQC</math>. Determine the range of possible values for <math>s/t</math>.
 ==Solution==
-We draw a diagram to not lose points:
+<asy>
+import olympiad;
+unitsize(1inch);
+pair A,B,C,O,H,P,Q,i1,i2,i3,i4;
+//define dots
+A=3*dir(50);
+B=(0,0);
+C=right*2.76481496;
+O=circumcenter(A,B,C);
+H=orthocenter(A,B,C);
+i1=2*O-H;
+i2=2*i1-O;
+i3=2*H-O;
+i4=2*i3-H;
+//These points are for extending PQ. DO NOT DELETE!
+P=intersectionpoint(i2--i4,A--B);
+Q=intersectionpoint(i2--i4,A--C);
+//draw
+dot(P);
+dot(Q);
+draw(P--Q);
+dot(A);
+dot(B);
+dot(C);
+dot(O);
+dot(H);
+draw(A--B--C--cycle);
+//label
+label("$A$",A,N);
+label("$B$",B,SW);
+label("$C$",C,SE);
+label("$P$",P,NW);
+label("$Q$",Q,NE);
+label("$O$",O,N);
+label("$H$",H,N);
+//change O and H label positions if interfering with other lines to be added
+//further editing: ABCPQOH are the dots to be further used. i1,i2,i3,i4 are for drawing assistance and are not to be used
+</asy>
+Lemma: <math>H</math> is the reflection of <math>O</math> over the angle bisector of <math>\angle BAC</math> (henceforth 'the' reflection)
+Proof: Let <math>H'</math> be the reflection of <math>O</math>, and let <math>B'</math> be the reflection of <math>B</math>.
+Then reflection takes <math>\angle ABH'</math> to <math>\angle AB'O</math>.
+<math>\Delta ABB'</math> is equilateral, and <math>O</math> lies on the perpendicular bisector of <math>\overline{AB}</math>
+It's well known that <math>O</math> lies strictly inside <math>\Delta ABC</math> (since it's acute), meaning that <math>\angle ABH' = \angle AB'O = 30^{\circ},</math> from which it follows that <math>\overline{BH'} \perp \overline{AC}</math> . Similarly,  <math>\overline{CH'} \perp \overline{AB}</math>. Since <math>H'</math> lies on two altitudes, <math>H'</math> is the orthocenter, as desired.
+End Lemma
+So <math>\overline{OH}</math> is perpendicular to the angle bisector of <math>\angle OAH</math>, which is the same line as the angle bisector of <math>\angle BAC</math>, meaning that <math>\Delta APQ</math> is equilateral.
+Let its side length be <math>s</math>, and let <math>PH=t</math>, where <math>0 < t < s, t \neq s/2</math> because <math>O</math> lies strictly within <math>\angle BAC</math>, as must <math>H</math>, the reflection of <math>O</math>. Also, it's easy to show that if <math>O=H</math> in a general triangle, it's equilateral, and we know <math>\Delta ABC</math> is not equilateral. Hence H is not on the bisector of <math>\angle BAC \implies t \neq s/2</math>. Let <math>\overrightarrow{BH}</math> intersect <math>\overline{AC}</math> at <math>P_B</math>.
+Since <math>\Delta HP_BQ</math> and <math>BP_BA</math> are 30-60-90 triangles, <math>AB=2AP_B=2(s-QP_B)=2(s-HQ/2)=2s-HQ=2s-(s-t)=s+t</math>
+Similarly, <math>AC=2s-t</math>
+The ratio <math>\frac{[APQ]}{[ABC]-[APQ]}</math> is <math>\frac{AP \cdot AQ}{AB \cdot AC - AP \cdot AQ} = \frac{s^2}{(s+t)(2s-t)-s^2}</math>
+The denominator equals <math>(1.5s)^2-(.5s-t)^2-s^2</math> where <math>.5s-t</math> can equal any value in <math>(-.5s, .5s)</math> except <math>0</math>. Therefore, the denominator can equal any value in <math>(s^2, 5s^2/4)</math>, and the ratio is any value in <math>\boxed{\left(\frac{4}{5},1\right)}.</math>
+Note: It's easy to show that for any point <math>H</math> on <math>\overline{PQ}</math> except the midpoint, Points B and C can be validly defined to make an acute, non-equilateral triangle.
+==Solution 2==
+Let <math>J</math> be the farthest point on the circumcircle of <math>\triangle{ABC}</math> from line <math>BC</math>.
+Lemma: Line <math>AJ</math>||Line <math>OH</math>
+Proof: Set <math>b=-\dfrac{1}{2}+i\dfrac{\sqrt{3}}{2}</math> and <math>c=-\dfrac{1}{2}-i\dfrac{\sqrt{3}}{2}</math>, and <math>a</math> on the unit circle. It is well known that <math>o=0</math> and <math>h=a+b+c</math>, so we have <math>h-o=a+b+c=a-1=a-j</math>, so <math>\dfrac{a-j}{h-o}</math> is real and thus the 2 lines are parallel.
+WLOG let <math>A</math> be in the first quadrant. Clearly by the above lemma <math>OH</math> must intersect line <math>BC</math> closer to <math>B</math> than to <math>C</math>. Intersect <math>AJ</math> and <math>BC</math> at <math>D</math> and <math>OH</math> and <math>BC</math> at <math>E</math>. We clearly have <math>0 < \dfrac{\overarc{JC}-\overarc{AB}}{2} = \dfrac{120-\overarc{AC}}{2} = \angle{ADB} = \angle{OEC} < 30 = \angle{OBC}</math>, <math>OH</math> must intersect <math>AB</math>. We also have, letting the intersection of line <math>OH</math> and line <math>AC</math> be <math>Q</math>, and letting intersection of <math>OH</math> and <math>AB</math> be <math>P</math>, <math>\angle{OQA} = \angle{JAB} = \dfrac{\overarc{JB}}{2} = 60</math>. Since <math>\angle{OCA}=\angle{BCA}-\angle{BCO} < 90-30 =\angle{OQA}</math>, and <math>\angle{OQC} = 120>\angle{OAC}</math>, <math>OH</math> also intersects <math>AC</math>. We have <math>\angle{OPA}=\angle{PAJ}=60</math>, so <math>\triangle{APQ}</math> is equilateral. Letting <math>AJ=2x</math>, and letting the foot of the perpendicular from <math>O</math> to <math>AJ</math> be <math>L</math>, we have <math>OL=\sqrt{1-x^{2}}</math>, and since <math>OL</math> is an altitude of <math>\triangle{APQ}</math>, we have <math>[APQ]=\dfrac{OL^{2}\sqrt{3}}{3} = \dfrac{\sqrt{3}(1-x^{2})}{3}</math>. Letting the foot of the perpendicular from <math>A</math> to <math>OJ</math> be <math>K</math>, we have <math>\triangle{JKA}\sim \triangle{JLO}</math> by AA with ratio <math>\dfrac{JA}{JO} = 2x</math>. Therefore, <math>JK = 2x(JL) = 2x^{2}</math>. Letting <math>D</math> be the foot of the altitude from <math>J</math> to <math>BC</math>, we have <math>KD=JD-JK=\dfrac{3}{2}-2x^{2}</math>, since <math>re(B)=re(C) \implies JD=re(j)-(-\dfrac{1}{2})=\dfrac{3}{2}</math>. Thus, since <math>BC=\sqrt{3}</math> we have <math>[ABC]=\dfrac{(\dfrac{3}{2}-2x^{2})(\sqrt{3})}{2} = \dfrac{(3-4x^{2})(\sqrt{3})}{2}</math>, so <math>[PQCB]=[ABC]-[APQ]=\dfrac{(5-8x^{2})(\sqrt{3})}{12}</math>, so <math>\dfrac{[APQ]}{[PQCB]} = \dfrac{4-4x^{2}}{5-8x^{2}} = \dfrac{1}{2}+\dfrac{3}{10-16x^{2}}</math>. We have <math>x=\sin(\dfrac{JOA}{2})</math>, with <math>0<120-2\angle{ACB}=\angle{JOA}<60</math>, so <math>x</math> can be anything in the interval <math>(0, \dfrac{1}{2})</math>. Therefore, the desired range is <math>(\dfrac{4}{5}, 1)</math>.
+Solution by Shaddoll
-'''Part a'''
+==See Also==
-'''Part b'''
+{{USAJMO box|year=2014|num-b=1|num-a=3}}