Difference between revisions of "Isogonal conjugate"
(→Isogonic center’s conjugate point) |
(→Three pare isogonal points) |
||
Line 914: | Line 914: | ||
'''vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss''' | '''vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss''' | ||
− | ==Three | + | ==Three pairs isogonal points== |
[[File:Shar 2024 20.png|400px|right]] | [[File:Shar 2024 20.png|400px|right]] | ||
Let a triangle <math>ABC,</math> points <math>D</math> and <math>E \in AD</math> be given, <math>F = CD \cap BE.</math> | Let a triangle <math>ABC,</math> points <math>D</math> and <math>E \in AD</math> be given, <math>F = CD \cap BE.</math> | ||
Line 932: | Line 932: | ||
<cmath>\frac {AE \cdot BF \cdot CD}{AD \cdot BE \cdot CF} = \frac{AD' \cdot BE' \cdot CF'}{AE' \cdot BF' \cdot CD'} = \frac {\sin \varphi_A \cdot \sin \varphi_B \cdot \sin \varphi_C}{\sin (\alpha - \varphi_A) \cdot \sin (\beta - \varphi_B) \cdot \sin (\gamma - \varphi_C)}.</cmath> | <cmath>\frac {AE \cdot BF \cdot CD}{AD \cdot BE \cdot CF} = \frac{AD' \cdot BE' \cdot CF'}{AE' \cdot BF' \cdot CD'} = \frac {\sin \varphi_A \cdot \sin \varphi_B \cdot \sin \varphi_C}{\sin (\alpha - \varphi_A) \cdot \sin (\beta - \varphi_B) \cdot \sin (\gamma - \varphi_C)}.</cmath> | ||
'''vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss''' | '''vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss''' | ||
+ | ==Ratio for three pairs of isogonal points== | ||
+ | [[File:Shar 2024 20.png|400px|right]] | ||
+ | Let a triangle <math>ABC,</math> points <math>D</math> and <math>E \in AD</math> be given, <math>F = CD \cap BE.</math> | ||
+ | Points <math>D', E'</math> and <math>F'</math> are the isogonal conjugate of the points <math>D, E,</math> and <math>F,</math> respectively, with respect to <math>\triangle ABC.</math> | ||
+ | |||
+ | Denote <math>R</math> and <math>R'</math> the circumradii of triangles <math>\triangle DEF</math> and <math>\triangle D'E'F',</math> respectively. | ||
+ | |||
+ | Prove that <math>\frac {AD \cdot BE \cdot CF}{R} = \frac {AE' \cdot BF' \cdot CD'}{R'}.</math> | ||
+ | |||
+ | <i><b>Proof</b></i> | ||
+ | |||
+ | Denote <math>\frac {AD}{DE} = u, \frac {BE}{EF} = w, \frac {CF}{FD} = v.</math> | ||
+ | <math>[DEF] = 1,</math> where <math>[X]</math> is the area of the figure <math>X.</math> | ||
+ | <cmath>\frac {[ADF]}{[DEF]} = \frac {AD}{DE} = u, \frac {[ACF]}{[DEF]} = \frac {[ACF]}{[ADF]} \cdot \frac {[ADF]}{[DEF]} = uv.</cmath> | ||
+ | Similarly, <cmath>\frac {[CFE]}{[DEF]} = v, \frac {[BCE]}{[DEF]} = vw, \frac {[BDE]}{[DEF]} = w, \frac {[ABD]}{[DEF]} = uw.</cmath> | ||
+ | <cmath>\frac {[ABC]}{[DEF]} = 1 + u + v + w + uv + uw + vw = (1 + u)(1 + v)(1 + w) - uvw = \frac {AE \cdot BF \cdot CD}{DE \cdot DF \cdot EF} - \frac {AD \cdot BE \cdot CF}{DE \cdot DF \cdot EF}.</cmath> | ||
+ | <cmath>\frac {DE \cdot DF \cdot EF}{4R} = [DEF] \implies [ABC] = \frac {AD \cdot BE \cdot CF}{4R} \cdot \left ( \frac {AE \cdot BF \cdot CD}{BE \cdot CF \cdot AD}-1 \right).</cmath> | ||
+ | Similarly, <cmath>[ABC] = \frac {AE' \cdot BF' \cdot CD'}{4R'} \cdot \left ( \frac {AD' \cdot BE' \cdot CD}{AE' \cdot BF' \cdot CD'}-1 \right).</cmath> | ||
+ | It is known that <math>\frac {AD}{AE} \cdot \frac {BE}{BF} \cdot \frac {CF}{CD} = \frac {AE'}{AD'} \cdot \frac {BF'}{BE'} \cdot \frac {CD'}{CF'},</math> therefore | ||
+ | <cmath>\frac {AD \cdot BE \cdot CF}{4R} = \frac {AE' \cdot BF' \cdot CD'}{4R'}.</cmath> | ||
+ | Comment: The main idea of the proof was found by Leonid Shatunov. | ||
+ | |||
+ | '''vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss''' | ||
[[Category:Geometry]] | [[Category:Geometry]] |
Revision as of 08:28, 18 April 2024
Isogonal conjugates are pairs of points in the plane with respect to a certain triangle.
Contents
- 1 The isogonal theorem
- 2 Parallel segments
- 3 Perpendicularity
- 4 Fixed point
- 5 Bisector
- 6 Isogonal of the diagonal of a quadrilateral
- 7 Isogonals in trapezium
- 8 Isogonals in complete quadrilateral
- 9 Isogonal of the bisector of the triangle
- 10 Points on isogonals
- 11 Trapezoid
- 12 IMO 2007 Short list/G3
- 13 Definition of isogonal conjugate of a point
- 14 Three points
- 15 Second definition
- 16 Distance to the sides of the triangle
- 17 Sign of isogonally conjugate points
- 18 Circumcircle of pedal triangles
- 19 Common circumcircle of the pedal triangles as the sign of isogonally conjugate points
- 20 Two pares of isogonally conjugate points
- 21 Circles
- 22 Equidistant isogonal conjugate points
- 23 1995 USAMO Problems/Problem 3
- 24 2011 USAMO Problems/Problem 5
- 25 2024 Sharygin olimpiad Problem 16
- 26 Simplified distance formula for isogonal points
- 27 Point on circumcircle
- 28 Fixed point on circumcircle
- 29 Distance formula for isogonal points
- 30 Miquel point for isogonal conjugate points
- 31 Point on circumcircle
- 32 Isogonal of line BC with respect to angle BAC
- 33 Isogonal bijection lines and points
- 34 Miquel point for two pare isogonal points
- 35 Isogonic center’s conjugate point
- 36 Three pairs isogonal points
- 37 Ratio for three pairs of isogonal points
The isogonal theorem
Isogonal lines definition
Let a line and a point
lying on
be given. A pair of lines symmetric with respect to
and containing the point
be called isogonals with respect to the pair
Sometimes it is convenient to take one pair of isogonals as the base one, for example, and
are the base pair. Then we call the remaining pairs as isogonals with respect to the angle
Projective transformation
It is known that the transformation that maps a point with coordinates into a point with coordinates
is projective.
If the abscissa axis coincides with the line and the origin coincides with the point
then the isogonals define the equations
and the lines
symmetrical with respect to the line
become their images.
It is clear that, under the converse transformation (also projective), such pairs of lines become isogonals, and the points equidistant from lie on the isogonals.
The isogonal theorem
Let two pairs of isogonals and
with respect to the pair
be given. Denote
Prove that and
are the isogonals with respect to the pair
Proof
Let us perform a projective transformation of the plane that maps the point into a point at infinity and the line
maps to itself. In this case, the isogonals turn into a pair of straight lines parallel to
and equidistant from
The converse (also projective) transformation maps the points equidistant from onto isogonals. We denote the image and the preimage with the same symbols.
Let the images of isogonals are vertical lines. Let coordinates of images of points be
Equation of a straight line
is
Equation of a straight line is
The abscissa of the point
is
Equation of a straight line is
Equation of a straight line is
The abscissa of the point
is
Preimages of the points and
lie on the isogonals.
The isogonal theorem in the case of parallel lines
Let and
are isogonals with respect
Let lines and
intersect at point
Prove that and line
through
parallel to
are the isogonals with respect
Proof
The preimage of is located at infinity on the line
The equality implies the equality the slopes modulo of
and
to the bisector of
Converse theorem
Let lines and
intersect at point
Let and
be the isogonals with respect
Prove that and
are isogonals with respect
Proof
The preimage of is located at infinity on the line
so the slope of
is known.
Suppose that
The segment and the lines
are fixed
intersects
at
but there is the only point where line intersect
Сontradiction.
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Parallel segments
Let triangle be given. Let
and
be the isogonals with respect
Let
Prove that lies on bisector of
and
Proof
Both assertions follow from The isogonal theorem in the case of parallel lines
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Perpendicularity
Let triangle be given. Right triangles
and
with hypotenuses
and
are constructed on sides
and
to the outer (inner) side of
Let
Prove that
Proof
Let be the bisector of
and
are isogonals with respect to the pair
and
are isogonals with respect to the pair
and
are isogonals with respect to the pair
in accordance with The isogonal theorem.
is the diameter of circumcircle of
Circumradius and altitude are isogonals with respect bisector and vertex of triangle, so
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Fixed point
Let fixed triangle be given. Let points
and
on sidelines
and
respectively be the arbitrary points.
Let be the point on sideline
such that
Prove that line
pass through the fixed point.
Proof
We will prove that point symmetric
with respect
lies on
.
and
are isogonals with respect to
points
and
lie on isogonals with respect to
in accordance with The isogonal theorem.
Point symmetric
with respect
lies on isogonal
with respect to
that is
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Bisector
Let a convex quadrilateral be given. Let
and
be the incenters of triangles
and
respectively.
Let and
be the A-excenters of triangles
and
respectively.
Prove that is the bisector of
Proof
and
are isogonals with respect to the angle
and
are isogonals with respect to the angle
in accordance with The isogonal theorem.
Denote
WLOG,
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Isogonal of the diagonal of a quadrilateral
Given a quadrilateral and a point
on its diagonal such that
Let
Prove that
Proof
Let us perform a projective transformation of the plane that maps the point to a point at infinity and the line
into itself.
In this case, the images of points and
are equidistant from the image of
the point (midpoint of
lies on
contains the midpoints of
and
is the Gauss line of the complete quadrilateral
bisects
the preimages of the points and
lie on the isogonals
and
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Isogonals in trapezium
Let the trapezoid be given. Denote
The point on the smaller base
is such that
Prove that
Proof
Therefore
and
are isogonals with respect
Let us perform a projective transformation of the plane that maps the point to a point at infinity and the line
into itself.
In this case, the images of points and
are equidistant from the image of
contains the midpoints of
and
, that is,
is the Gauss line of the complete quadrilateral
bisects
The preimages of the points and
lie on the isogonals
and
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Isogonals in complete quadrilateral
Let complete quadrilateral be given. Let
be the Miquel point of
Prove that is isogonal to
and
is isogonal to
with respect
Proof
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Isogonal of the bisector of the triangle
The triangle be given. The point
chosen on the bisector
Denote
Prove that
Proof
Let us perform a projective transformation of the plane that maps the point to a point at infinity and the line
into itself.
In this case, the images of segments and
are equidistant from the image of
Image of point is midpoint of image
and midpoint image
Image is parallelogramm
distances from
and
to
are equal
Preimages and
are isogonals with respect
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Points on isogonals
The triangle be given. The point
chosen on
The point
chosen on
such that
and
are isogonals with respect
Prove that
Proof
Denote
We use the Law of Sines and get:
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Trapezoid
The lateral side of the trapezoid
is perpendicular to the bases, point
is the intersection point of the diagonals
.
Point is taken on the circumcircle
of triangle
diametrically opposite to point
Prove that
Proof
WLOG, is not the diameter of
Let sidelines
and
intersect
at points
and
respectively.
is rectangle
is isogonal to
with respect
is isogonal to
with respect
In accordance with The isogonal theorem in case parallel lines
is isogonal to
with respect
in accordance with Converse theorem for The isogonal theorem in case parallel lines.
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
IMO 2007 Short list/G3
The diagonals of a trapezoid intersect at point
Point lies between the parallel lines
and
such that
and line
separates points
and
Prove that
Proof
and
are isogonals with respect
is isogonal to
with respect
From the converse of The isogonal theorem we get
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Definition of isogonal conjugate of a point
Let triangle be given. Let
be the circumcircle of
Let point
be in the plane of
Denote by
the lines
respectively. Denote by
the lines
,
,
, respectively.
Denote by
,
,
the reflections of
,
,
over the angle bisectors of angles
,
,
, respectively.
Prove that lines ,
,
concur at a point
This point is called the isogonal conjugate of
with respect to triangle
.
Proof
By our constructions of the lines ,
, and this statement remains true after permuting
. Therefore by the trigonometric form of Ceva's Theorem
so again by the trigonometric form of Ceva, the lines
concur, as was to be proven.
Corollary
Let points P and Q lie on the isogonals with respect angles and
of triangle
Then these points lie on isogonals with respect angle
Corollary 2
Let point be in the sideline
of
Then the isogonal conjugate of a point is a point
Points and
do not have an isogonally conjugate point.
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Three points
Let fixed triangle be given. Let the arbitrary point
not be on sidelines of
Let
be the point on isogonal of
with respect angle
Let
be the crosspoint of isogonal of
with respect angle
and isogonal of
with respect angle
Prove that lines and
are concurrent.
Proof
Denote
and
are isogonals with respect
and S lie on isogonals of
is isogonal conjugated of
with respect
and
lie on isogonals of
Therefore points and
lie on the same line which is isogonal to
with respect
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Second definition
Let triangle be given. Let point
lies in the plane of
Let the reflections of
in the sidelines
be
Then the circumcenter of the
is the isogonal conjugate of
Points and
have not isogonal conjugate points.
Another points of sidelines have points
respectively as isogonal conjugate points.
Proof
is common therefore
Similarly
is the circumcenter of the
From definition 1 we get that is the isogonal conjugate of
It is clear that each point has the unique isogonal conjugate point.
Let point be the point with barycentric coordinates
Then
has barycentric coordinates
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Distance to the sides of the triangle
Let be the isogonal conjugate of a point
with respect to a triangle
Let and
be the projection
on sides
and
respectively.
Let and
be the projection
on sides
and
respectively.
Then
Proof
Let
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Sign of isogonally conjugate points
Let triangle and points
and
inside it be given.
Let be the projections
on sides
respectively.
Let be the projections
on sides
respectively.
Let Prove that point
is the isogonal conjugate of a point
with respect to a triangle
One can prove a similar theorem in the case outside
Proof
Denote
Similarly
Hence point
is the isogonal conjugate of a point
with respect to a triangle
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Circumcircle of pedal triangles
Let be the isogonal conjugate of a point
with respect to a triangle
Let be the projection
on sides
respectively.
Let be the projection
on sides
respectively.
Prove that points are concyclic.
The midpoint is circumcenter of
Proof
Let
Hence points are concyclic.
is trapezoid,
the midpoint is circumcenter of
Similarly points are concyclic and points
are concyclic.
Therefore points are concyclic, so the midpoint
is circumcenter of
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Common circumcircle of the pedal triangles as the sign of isogonally conjugate points
Let triangle and points
and
inside it be given. Let
be the projections
on sides
respectively.
Let
be the projections
on sides
respectively.
Let points be concyclic and none of them lies on the sidelines of
Then point is the isogonal conjugate of a point
with respect to a triangle
This follows from the uniqueness of the conjugate point and the fact that the line intersects the circle in at most two points.
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Two pares of isogonally conjugate points
Let triangle and points
and
be given. Let points
and
be the isogonal conjugate of a points
and
with respect to a triangle
respectively.
Let cross
at
and
cross
at
Prove that point is the isogonal conjugate of a point
with respect to
Proof
There are two pairs of isogonals and
with respect to the angle
are isogonals with respect to the
in accordance with The isogonal theorem.
Similarly are the isogonals with respect to the
Therefore the point is the isogonal conjugate of a point
with respect to
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Circles
Let be the isogonal conjugate of a point
with respect to a triangle
Let be the circumcenter of
Let be the circumcenter of
Prove that points and
are inverses with respect to the circumcircle of
Proof
The circumcenter of point
and points
and
lies on the perpendicular bisector of
Similarly
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Equidistant isogonal conjugate points
Let triangle with incenter
be given.
Denote
Let point be the isogonal conjugate of the point
with respect to
Prove that iff
Proof
1. Let WLOG,
Point
Point is the isogonal conjugate of the point
with respect to
So points
and
are concyclic.
Let Then
is the center of
2. Let
Points and
are symmetric with respect
Suppose that
Let be the center of
be the center of
It is known that points and
are inverted with respect to the circumcircle of
Points and
belong to bisector
Therefore divide
and
WLOG (see diagram) contradiction.
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
1995 USAMO Problems/Problem 3
Given a nonisosceles, nonright triangle let
denote the center of its circumscribed circle, and let
and
be the midpoints of sides
and
respectively. Point
is located on the ray
so that
is similar to
. Points
and
on rays
and
respectively, are defined similarly. Prove that lines
and
are concurrent.
Solution
Let be the altitude of
Hence
and
are isogonals with respect to the angle
and
are isogonals with respect to the angle
Similarly and
are isogonals with respect to
Similarly and
are isogonals with respect to
Let be the centroid of
is the isogonal conjugate of a point
with respect to a triangle
Corollary
If median and symmedian start from any vertex of the triangle, then the angle formed by the symmedian and the angle side has the same measure as the angle between the median and the other side of the angle.
are medians, therefore
are symmedians, so the three symmedians meet at a point which is triangle center called the Lemoine point.
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
2011 USAMO Problems/Problem 5
Let be a given point inside quadrilateral
. Points
and
are located within
such that
,
,
,
.
Prove that if and only if
.
Solution
Case 1 The lines and
are not parallel. Denote
Point
isogonal conjugate of a point
with respect to a triangle
and
are isogonals with respect to
Similarly point isogonal conjugate of a point
with respect to a triangle
and
are isogonals with respect to
Therefore points lies on the isogonal
with respect to
is not parallel to
or
Case 2 We use The isogonal theorem in case parallel lines and get
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
2024 Sharygin olimpiad Problem 16
Let and
be the bisectors of a triangle
The segments and
meet at point
Let
be the projection of
to
Points and
on the sides
and
respectively, are such that
Prove that
Proof
is the common side)
is the midpoint
Denote the inradius of
is the base of perpendicular from
to
It is known that
(see Division of bisector for details.)
is incenter of
is isogonal conjugate of E with respect
Another solution see 2024.2C_Problem_16
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Simplified distance formula for isogonal points
Let triangle points
and
and
be given. Let point
be the isogonal conjugate of a point
with respect to a triangle
Prove that
Proof
and
are both subtended by arc
Similarly
Product of isogonal segments
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Point on circumcircle
Let triangle points
and
be given.
Denote
Prove that
Proof
WLOG, the order of the points is as shown on diagram.
The spiral symilarity centered at maps
to
and point
to point
is the external angle of
Corollary
is the isogonal conjugate to
with respect
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Fixed point on circumcircle
Let triangle point
on circumcircle
and point
be given.
Point lies on
point
be the isogonal conjugate of a point
with respect to a triangle
Prove that is fixed point and not depends from position of
Proof
WLOG, the order of points on sideline is point
is closer to
than to
Denote
Spiral similarity centered at which maps
into
transform point
into point
Points
and
are collinear.
It is known ( Ratio of isogonal segments) that
We use the ratio of the areas and get:
Denote
Therefore
which means ( Problems | Simple) that
is the radical axes of
and
and not depends from position of
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Distance formula for isogonal points
Let triangle and point
be given.
Let point be the isogonal conjugate of a point
with respect to a triangle
Let lines and
cross sideline
at
and
and circumcircle of
at
and
respectively.
We apply the Isogonal’s property and get
We apply the Ptolemy's theorem to
and get
We apply the barycentric coordinates and get
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Miquel point for isogonal conjugate points
Let triangle points
and
be given. Let point
be the isogonal conjugate of a point
with respect to a triangle
Let
be the Miquel point of a complete quadrilateral
Prove that lies on the circumcircle of
Proof
Point is the isogonal conjugate of a point
with respect to a triangle
so point
is the isogonal conjugate of a point
with respect to a triangle
Points and
lies on the same line, therefore
Point
lies on circles
and
spiral similarity centered at
transform triangle
to
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Point on circumcircle
Let triangle and points
and
be given.
Let
Let lines and
be the isogonals with respect to the angle
Let be an arbitrary point on
Prove that lies on
Simplified problem
Let and points
and
be given,
Let lines and
be the isogonals with respect to
Prove that
Proof, Simplified problem
points are concyclic on
Proof
Let points and
be the isogonal conjugate of a points
and
with respect to a triangle
It is known that
points
are concyclic on
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Isogonal of line BC with respect to angle BAC
Let triangle be given,
Let lines and
be the isogonals with respect to
Prove that is tangent to
Proof
Let and
be the circumcenter and the orthocenter of
respectively.
is isogonal to
with respect to
is tangent to
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Isogonal bijection lines and points
Let triangle and line
be given,
Define the point with property
Prove that is equal the angle
between
and
Proof
WLOG, the configuration is the same as shown on diagram, is the tangent to
is isogonal to
is isogonal to
with respect to
A bijection has been established between the set of lines parallel to a given one and the set of points of the circumcircle.
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Miquel point for two pare isogonal points
Let triangle and points
and
be given.
Let points and
be the isogonal conjugate of the points
and
with respect to
is the Miquel point of quadrilateral
Prove that
Proof
Denote
Then is the Miquel point of quadrilateral
Denote
Let be the point with property
WLOG, configuration is similar as shown in diagram.
( Isogonal_bijection_lines_and_points).
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Isogonic center’s conjugate point
Let triangle with isogonic center
or
be given. Denote
Let line be the axial symmetry of line
according to the sideline
Define lines and
similarly.
Prove that the lines and
are concurrent.
Proof
Let be the incenter of
Let
is simmetric to
with respect
The diameter of
lies on
Therefore is the isogonal conjugate of
with respect to
Similarly and
are the isogonal conjugate of
and
so point
is the isogonal conjugate of point
with respect to
The second diagram show construction in the case The proof is similar.
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Three pairs isogonal points
Let a triangle points
and
be given,
Points
and
are the isogonal conjugate of the points
and
respectively, with respect to
Prove that
Proof
Denote
We use isogonal properties and get
By applying the Law of Sines, we get
Symilarly,
We multiply these equations and get
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss
Ratio for three pairs of isogonal points
Let a triangle points
and
be given,
Points and
are the isogonal conjugate of the points
and
respectively, with respect to
Denote and
the circumradii of triangles
and
respectively.
Prove that
Proof
Denote
where
is the area of the figure
Similarly,
Similarly,
It is known that
therefore
Comment: The main idea of the proof was found by Leonid Shatunov.
vladimir.shelomovskii@gmail.com, vvsss