Difference between revisions of "2020 AIME I Problems/Problem 12"

Latest revision as of 02:50, 21 January 2024

Problem

Let $n$ be the least positive integer for which $149^n-2^n$ is divisible by $3^3\cdot5^5\cdot7^7.$ Find the number of positive integer divisors of $n.$

Solution 1

As usual, denote $v_p(n)$ the highest power of prime $p$ that divides $n$ . Lifting the Exponent shows that $3=v_3(149^n-2^n) = v_3(n) + v_3(147) = v_3(n)+1$ so thus, $3^2$ divides $n$ . It also shows that $7=v_7(149^n-2^n) = v_7(n) + v_7(147) = v_7(n)+2$ so thus, $7^5$ divides $n$ .

Now, setting $n = 4c$ (necessitated by $149^n \equiv 2^n \pmod 5$ in order to set up LTE), we see $v_5(149^{4c}-2^{4c}) = v_5(149^{4c}-16^{c})$ and since $149^{4} \equiv 1 \pmod{25}$ and $16^1 \equiv 16 \pmod{25}$ then $v_5(149^{4c}-2^{4c})=v_5(149^4-16)+v_5(c)=1+v_5(c)$ meaning that we have that by LTE, $5^4 | c$ and $4 \cdot 5^4$ divides $n$ .

Since $3^2$ , $7^5$ and $4\cdot 5^4$ all divide $n$ , the smallest value of $n$ working is their LCM, also $3^2 \cdot 7^5 \cdot 4 \cdot 5^4 = 2^2 \cdot 3^2 \cdot 5^4 \cdot 7^5$ . Thus the number of divisors is $(2+1)(2+1)(4+1)(5+1) = \boxed{270}$ .

~kevinmathz

clarified by another user

notation note from another user

Note

We were able to use LTE with 3 and 7 but not 5 because in order to use LTE, we need $ p \mid x-y $.

Obviously, $ 149^n \equiv 2^n \pmod{3} $ implies $ 149^n - 2^n \equiv 0 \pmod{3} $, so LTE works here.

Furthermore, $ 149^n \equiv 2^n \pmod{7} $ implies $ 149^n - 2^n \equiv 0 \pmod{7} $, so LTE works here.

However, when we get to the case of 5, we see that $ 149^n \equiv 2^n \pmod{5} $ doesn't always hold; specifically, this is only valid when $ n $ is a multiple of $ 4 $, which is why we let $ n = 4c $ in the solution.

mathboy282

Solution 2 (Simpler, just basic mods and Fermat's theorem)

Note that for all $n$ , $149^n - 2^n$ is divisible by $149-2 = 147$ by difference of $n$ th powers. That is $3\cdot7^2$ , so now we can clearly see that the smallest $n$ to make the expression divisible by $3^3$ is just $3^2$ . Similarly, we can reason that the smallest $n$ to make the expression divisible by $7^7$ is just $7^5$ .

Finally, for $5^5$ , take $\pmod {5}$ and $\pmod {25}$ of each quantity (They happen to both be $-1$ and $2$ respectively, so you only need to compute once). One knows from Fermat's theorem that the maximum possible minimum $n$ for divisibility by $5$ is $4$ , and other values are factors of $4$ . Testing all of them(just $1$ , $2$ , $4$ using mods-not too bad), $4$ is indeed the smallest value to make the expression divisible by $5$ , and this clearly is NOT divisible by $25$ . Therefore, the smallest $n$ to make this expression divisible by $5^5$ is $2^2 \cdot 5^4$ .

Calculating the LCM of all these, one gets $2^2 \cdot 3^2 \cdot 5^4 \cdot 7^5$ . Using the factor counting formula, the answer is $3\cdot3\cdot5\cdot6$ = $\boxed{270}$ .

~Solution by thanosaops

~formatted by MY-2 and pandyhu2001

Solution 3 (Elementary and Thorough)

As usual, denote $v_p(n)$ the highest power of prime $p$ that divides $n$ . For divisibility by $3^3$ , notice that $v_3(149^3 - 2^3) = 2$ as $149^3 - 2^3 =$ $(147)(149^2 + 2\cdot149 + 2^2)$ , and upon checking mods, $149^2 + 2\cdot149 + 2^2$ is divisible by $3$ but not $9$ . In addition, $149^9 - 2^9$ is divisible by $3^3$ because $149^9 - 2^9 = (149^3 - 2^3)(149^6 + 149^3\cdot2^3 + 2^6)$ , and the rightmost factor equates to $1 + 1 + 1 \pmod{3} \equiv 0 \pmod{3}$ . In fact, $n = 9 = 3^2$ is the least possible choice to ensure divisibility by $3^3$ because if $n = a \cdot 3^b$ , with $3 \nmid a$ and $b < 2$ , we write $149^{a \cdot 3^b} - 2^{a \cdot 3^b} = (149^{3^b} - 2^{3^b})(149^{3^b(a - 1)} + 149^{3^b(a - 2)}\cdot2^{3^b}+\cdots2^{3^b(a - 1)}).$ Then, the rightmost factor is equivalent to $\pm a \pmod{3} \not\equiv 0 \pmod{3}$ , and $v_3(149^{3^b} - 2^{3^b}) = b + 1 < 3$ .

For divisibility by $7^7$ , we'll induct, claiming that $v_7(149^{7^k} - 2^{7^k}) = k + 2$ for whole numbers $k$ . The base case is clear. Then, $v_7(149^{7^{k+1}} - 2^{7^{k+1}}) = v_7(149^{7^k} - 2^{7^k}) + v_7(149^{6\cdot7^k} + 2^{7^k}\cdot149^{5\cdot7^k} + \cdots + 2^{5\cdot7^k}\cdot149^{7^k} + 2^{6\cdot7^k}).$ By the induction hypothesis, $v_7(149^{7^k} - 2^{7^k}) = k + 2$ . Then, notice that $S(k) = 149^{6\cdot7^k} + 2^{7^k}\cdot149^{5\cdot7^k} + \cdots + 2^{5\cdot7^k}\cdot149^{7^k} + 2^{6\cdot7^k} \equiv 7 \cdot 2^{6\cdot7^k}\pmod{7} \equiv 7 \cdot 2^{6\cdot7^k}\pmod{49}.$ This tells us that $S(k)$ is divisible by $7$ , but not $49$ so that $v_7\left(S(k)\right) = 1$ , completing our induction. We can verify that $7^5$ is the least choice of $n$ to ensure divisibility by $7^7$ by arguing similarly to the $3^3$ case.

Finally, for $5^5$ , we take the powers of $149$ and $2$ in mod $5$ and mod $25$ . Writing out these mods, we have that $149^n \equiv 2^n \pmod{5}$ if and only if $4 | n$ , in which $149^n \equiv 2^n \equiv 1 \pmod{5}$ . So here we claim that $v_5(149^{4\cdot5^k} - 2^{4\cdot5^k}) = k + 1$ and perform yet another induction. The base case is true: $5 | 149^4 - 2^4$ , but $149^4 - 2^4 \equiv 1 - 16 \pmod{25}$ . Now then, assuming the induction statement to hold for some $k$ , $v_5(149^{4\cdot5^{k+1}} - 2^{4\cdot5^{k+1}}) = (k+1) + v_5(149^{4\cdot4\cdot5^k}+2^{4\cdot5^k}\cdot149^{3\cdot4\cdot5^k}+\cdots+2^{3\cdot4\cdot5^k}\cdot149^{4\cdot5^k}+2^{4\cdot4\cdot5^k}).$ Note that $S'(k) = 149^{4\cdot4\cdot5^k}+2^{4\cdot5^k}\cdot149^{3\cdot4\cdot5^k}+\cdots+2^{3\cdot4\cdot5^k}\cdot149^{4\cdot5^k}+2^{4\cdot4\cdot5^k}$ equates to $S''(k) = 1 + 2^{4\cdot5^k} + \cdots + 2^{16\cdot5^k}$ in both mod $5$ and mod $25$ . We notice that $S''(k) \equiv 0 \pmod{5}$ . Writing out the powers of $2$ mod $25$ , we have $S''(0) \equiv 5 \pmod{25}$ . Also $2^n \equiv 1 \pmod{25}$ when $n$ is a multiple of $20$ . Hence for $k > 0$ , $S''(k) \equiv 5 \mod{25}$ . Thus, $v_5\left(S'(k)\right) = 1$ , completing our induction. Applying the same argument from the previous two cases, $4\cdot5^4$ is the least choice to ensure divisibility by $5^5$ .

Our answer is the number of divisors of $\text{lcm}(3^2, 7^5, 2^2\cdot5^4) = 2^2 \cdot 3^2 \cdot 5^4 \cdot 7^5$ . It is $(2 + 1)(2 + 1)(4 + 1)(5 + 1) = \boxed{270}$ .

~hnkevin42

Solution 4 (Official MAA)

Analyze each prime power separately. Start with the case of $3^3$ . By the Binomial Theorem, $\begin{align*} 149^n - 2^n &= (147+2)^n - 2^n \\ &= \binom n1 \cdot 147 \cdot 2^{n-1} + \binom n2 \cdot 147^2 \cdot 2^{n-2}\\ &\qquad+ \binom n3 \cdot 147^3 \cdot 2^{n-3} + \cdots. \end{align*}$ Because $147$ is divisible by $3$ , all terms after the first two are divisible by $3^3$ , and the exponent of $3$ in the first term is less than that in the second term. Hence it is necessary and sufficient that $3^3 \mid 147n$ , that is, $3^2 \mid n$ . For the $7^7$ case, consider the same expansion as in the previous case. Because $147$ is divisible by $49 = 7^2$ , all terms after the first three are divisible by $7^7$ , and the exponent of $7$ in the first term is less than that in the second and third term. Hence it is necessary and sufficient that $7^7 \mid 147n$ , that is, $7^5 \mid n$ . For the $5^5$ case, working modulo $5$ gives $149^n - 2^n \equiv 4^n - 2^n = 2^n(2^n-1) \pmod 5$ , so it must be that $4 \mid n$ . Let $n = 4m$ , and let $c = 149^4 - 2^4 = (149^2-2^2)(149^2+2^2) = 147 \cdot 151 \cdot 22205$ . Note that $\frac c5$ is an integer not divisible by $5$ . Expand by the Binomial Theorem again to get $\begin{align*} (149^4)^m - (2^4)^m &= (c+16)^m - (16)^m \\ &= \binom m1 \cdot c \cdot 16^{m-1} + \binom m2 \cdot c^2 \cdot 16^{m-2} \\ &\qquad+ \binom m3 \cdot c^3 \cdot 16^{m-3} + \binom m4 \cdot c^4 \cdot 16^{m-4} + \cdots. \end{align*}$ All terms after the first four are divisible by $5^5$ , and the exponent of $5$ in the first term is less than that in the second, third, or fourth term. Hence it is necessary and sufficient that $5^5 \mid cm$ . Thus $5^4 \mid m$ , and it follows that $4 \cdot 5^4 \mid n$ . Therefore the least $n$ is $3^2 \cdot (2^2 \cdot 5^4) \cdot 7^5$ . The requested number of divisors is $(1+2)(1+2)(1+4)(1+5) = 270$ .

The results of the above cases can be generalized using the following lemma.

Lifting the Exponent Lemma: Let $p$ be an odd prime, and let $a$ and $b$ be integers relatively prime to $p$ such that $p \mid (a-b)$ . Let $n$ be a positive integer. Then the number of factors of $p$ that divide $a^n - b^n$ is equal to the number of factors of $p$ that divide $a-b$ plus the number of factors of $p$ that divide $n$ .

Video Solution

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O0BprEOVkjo ~ Math Gold Medalist

Revision as of 02:47, 21 January 2024 (view source) Mathboy282 (talk \| contribs) (→‎Solution 1) ← Older edit		Latest revision as of 02:50, 21 January 2024 (view source) Mathboy282 (talk \| contribs) (→‎Solution 1)
Line 7:		Line 7:


−	Now, setting <math>n = 4c</math> (necessitated by <math>149^n \equiv 2^n \pmod 5</math> in order to set up LTE), we see <cmath>v_5(149^{4c}-2^{4c}) = v_5(149^{4c}-16^{c})</cmath> and since <math>149^{4} \equiv 1 \pmod{25}</math> and <math>16^1 \equiv 16 \pmod{25}</math> then <math>v_5(149^{4c}-2^{4c})=1+v_5(c)</math> meaning that we have that by LTE, <math>5^4 \| c</math> and <math>4 \cdot 5^4</math> divides <math>n</math>.	+	Now, setting <math>n = 4c</math> (necessitated by <math>149^n \equiv 2^n \pmod 5</math> in order to set up LTE), we see <cmath>v_5(149^{4c}-2^{4c}) = v_5(149^{4c}-16^{c})</cmath> and since <math>149^{4} \equiv 1 \pmod{25}</math> and <math>16^1 \equiv 16 \pmod{25}</math> then <math>v_5(149^{4c}-2^{4c})=v_5(149^4-16)+v_5(c)=1+v_5(c)</math> meaning that we have that by LTE, <math>5^4 \| c</math> and <math>4 \cdot 5^4</math> divides <math>n</math>.

	Since <math>3^2</math>, <math>7^5</math> and <math>4\cdot 5^4</math> all divide <math>n</math>, the smallest value of <math>n</math> working is their LCM, also <math>3^2 \cdot 7^5 \cdot 4 \cdot 5^4 = 2^2 \cdot 3^2 \cdot 5^4 \cdot 7^5</math>. Thus the number of divisors is <math>(2+1)(2+1)(4+1)(5+1) = \boxed{270}</math>.		Since <math>3^2</math>, <math>7^5</math> and <math>4\cdot 5^4</math> all divide <math>n</math>, the smallest value of <math>n</math> working is their LCM, also <math>3^2 \cdot 7^5 \cdot 4 \cdot 5^4 = 2^2 \cdot 3^2 \cdot 5^4 \cdot 7^5</math>. Thus the number of divisors is <math>(2+1)(2+1)(4+1)(5+1) = \boxed{270}</math>.

2020 AIME I (Problems • Answer Key • Resources)
Preceded by Problem 11	Followed by Problem 13
1 • 2 • 3 • 4 • 5 • 6 • 7 • 8 • 9 • 10 • 11 • 12 • 13 • 14 • 15
All AIME Problems and Solutions

Page

Toolbox

Search