Too much Oddness
by utkarshgupta, Dec 5, 2015, 2:13 PM
Problem (British MO 2015) :
In Oddesdon Primary School there are an odd number of classes. Each class contains an odd number of pupils. One pupil from each class will be chosen to form the school council. Prove that the following two statements are logically equivalent.
a) There are more ways to form a school council which includes an odd number of boys than ways to form a school council which includes an odd number of girls.
b) There are an odd number of classes which contain more boys than girls.
Solution
I will prove that
by induction on the number of classes.
Once this is implied, the other way is immediate (replace girls with boys)
Let the number of classes be
For
, the result is trivial.
Now let
Let
be the set of classes with number of boys greater than the number of girls and
the set of classes with number of girls greater than the number of boys.
There are two cases
Case
: 
I will show that for any council with number of girls odd can be mapped to a council with number of boys odd.
Let the class in
have the boy students as
and girl students as 
Consider a selection
in which the number of girls is odd.
Let
, then replacing
gives and arrangement in which number of boys is odd.
And since number of girls is more than the number of boys, here we are done.
Let
, due to parity, there exists some class
such that a boy has been selected in this class.
Correspond each boy to a girl in this class (some girls will be left out as they are more in number). Replacing this selected boy by it's corresponding girl gives a selection with odd number of boys.
Thus this case is done.
Case
: 
Consider some two elements
Then
is a system of
classes satisfying the problem conditions.
By induction hypothesis, the number of ways to select odd number of boys (
) is greater than number of ways to select odd number of girls (
) in the council.
Let
have
boys and
girls respectively.
Then the number of ways of selecting odd number of boys(
) from the
classes is
.
And the number of ways of selecting odd number of girls (
) from the
classes is 
Now observe that
Hence by induction, we are done.
In Oddesdon Primary School there are an odd number of classes. Each class contains an odd number of pupils. One pupil from each class will be chosen to form the school council. Prove that the following two statements are logically equivalent.
a) There are more ways to form a school council which includes an odd number of boys than ways to form a school council which includes an odd number of girls.
b) There are an odd number of classes which contain more boys than girls.
Solution
I will prove that

Once this is implied, the other way is immediate (replace girls with boys)
Let the number of classes be

For

Now let

Let


There are two cases
Case


I will show that for any council with number of girls odd can be mapped to a council with number of boys odd.
Let the class in



Consider a selection

Let


And since number of girls is more than the number of boys, here we are done.
Let


Correspond each boy to a girl in this class (some girls will be left out as they are more in number). Replacing this selected boy by it's corresponding girl gives a selection with odd number of boys.
Thus this case is done.
Case


Consider some two elements

Then


By induction hypothesis, the number of ways to select odd number of boys (


Let



Then the number of ways of selecting odd number of boys(



And the number of ways of selecting odd number of girls (



Now observe that

Hence by induction, we are done.