,
,
,
,
or even expressions of those terms combined as if that would make them defined. I have made this post to answer these questions once and for all, and I politely ask everyone to link this post to threads that are talking about this issue.
,
isn't even rigorously defined in this expression. What exactly do we mean by 
.
,
does not exist in the first place, although you will see why in a calculus course. So the point is that 
?
indeterminate? In analysis (the theory behind calculus and beyond), limits involving an algebraic combination of functions in an independent variable may often be evaluated by replacing these functions by their limits. However, if the expression obtained after this substitution does not provide sufficient information to determine the original limit, then the expression is called an indeterminate form. For example, we could say that 
,
or ![\[0/0, \infty/\infty, \infty-\infty, \infty \times 0\]](http://latex.artofproblemsolving.com/2/6/0/260f97a1cf1ea8722ff97a29b83bac7bfe83e577.png)
etc etc. So what makes something undefined? In the broader scope, something being undefined refers to an expression which is not assigned an interpretation or a value. A function is said to be undefined for points outside its domain. For example, the function 
given by the mapping 
is undefined for 
.
is undefined because dividing by ![\[\overline{\mathbb{R}}=\mathbb{R}\cup \{-\infty,+\infty\}.\]](http://latex.artofproblemsolving.com/9/9/3/993c78b62ec2c84b5d77daa8e9a8cd6f70fcf904.png)
So instead of treating infinity as an idea, we define infinity (positively and negatively, mind you) as actual numbers in the reals. The advantage of doing this is for two reasons. The first is because we can turn this thing into a totally ordered set. Specifically, we can let 
for each 
which means that via this order topology each subset has an infimum and supremum and 
is therefore compact. While this is nice from an analytic standpoint, extending the reals in this way can allow for interesting arithmetic! In ![\begin{align*}
a + \infty = \infty + a & = \infty, & a & \neq -\infty \\
a - \infty = -\infty + a & = -\infty, & a & \neq \infty \\
a \cdot (\pm\infty) = \pm\infty \cdot a & = \pm\infty, & a & \in (0, +\infty] \\
a \cdot (\pm\infty) = \pm\infty \cdot a & = \mp\infty, & a & \in [-\infty, 0) \\
\frac{a}{\pm\infty} & = 0, & a & \in \mathbb{R} \\
\frac{\pm\infty}{a} & = \pm\infty, & a & \in (0, +\infty) \\
\frac{\pm\infty}{a} & = \mp\infty, & a & \in (-\infty, 0).
\end{align*}](http://latex.artofproblemsolving.com/6/d/8/6d8fc1eca5c791d430a7168cd3b37a02104fa318.png)
So addition, multiplication, and division are all defined nicely. However, notice that we have some indeterminate forms here which are also undefined,![\[\infty-\infty,\frac{\pm\infty}{\pm\infty},\frac{\pm\infty}{0},0\cdot \pm\infty.\]](http://latex.artofproblemsolving.com/a/0/b/a0b67076efcc014c78b2023be1151c84b57c1503.png)
So while we define certain things, we also left others undefined/indeterminate in the process! However, in the context of measure theory it is common to define 
as greenturtle3141 noted below. I encourage to reread what he wrote, it's great stuff! As you may notice, though, dividing by ![\[\mathbb{C}^*=\mathbb{C}\cup\{\tilde{\infty}\}\]](http://latex.artofproblemsolving.com/8/4/e/84ed3d6ab237df970333b87beaef5311caa46185.png)
which we call the Riemann Sphere (it actually forms a sphere, pretty cool right?). As a note, 
means complex infinity, since we are in the complex plane now. Here's the catch: division by ![\[\frac{z}{0}=\tilde{\infty},\frac{z}{\tilde{\infty}}=0.\]](http://latex.artofproblemsolving.com/1/6/0/160cb939707708ff4e0930724df2928af11d7fd1.png)
where 
and 
Furthermore, we actually have some nice properties with multiplication that we didn't have before. In 
it holds that![\[\tilde{\infty}\times \tilde{\infty}=\tilde{\infty}\]](http://latex.artofproblemsolving.com/8/e/0/8e035b4841d20c5ad671c46355cc667ca01e533b.png)
but 
and 
are left as undefined (unless there is an explicit need to change that somehow). One could define the projectively extended reals as we did with ![\[{\widehat {\mathbb {R} }}=\mathbb {R} \cup \{\infty \}.\]](http://latex.artofproblemsolving.com/c/0/4/c044ff37849acad3b8b280b9753539225a1276ca.png)
They behave in a similar way to the Riemann Sphere, with division by 
?
.
is rounded to the nearest integer and then divided by 
,
Y by WorstIreliaNA, tastymath75025, DrMath, CaptainFlint, RadioActive, MathStudent2002, MSTang, LauraZed, mathisawesome2169, C-bass, PiDude314, bartle-doo, hotstuffFTW, Darn, zmyshatlp, ac_math, uwotm8, bluecarneal, ninjasrule34, boompenguinz, WOOT4444ForSnorlax2016, joey8189681, SHARKYBOY, El_Ectric, StopMakingMultis, r31415, hesa57, qwef, LadyKn1ght, ArrowHead, MathSlayer4444, Not_a_Username, swagchicken, WhaleVomit, aops777, rjiang16, TeeheeMarx, Mudkipswims42, mathguy623, song2sons, nine_plus_ten, VenusGuy, farmerboy, Anish_S, hzbest, irishfeet123, Benq, AwesomeToad, PhatSnorlax, Mathcounts829, can168, mathwizard888, stephy2003, DrMathIsMagikarp1, bostonkid, snorlaxPAWNchessm8, ohmcfifth, MathLearner01, Mrdavid445, abk2015, hwl0304, Pythag314, spartan168, picubed, slackroadia, TurtlePie, StarFrost7, blep, Dude156, phi_ftw1618, jonyj1005, banned5000, brainpopper, kvs, ythomashu, xuxin, zardum, mathguy24, AKAL3, rt03, yrnsmurf, math101010, violinist, Maths4J, somepeoplearebad, BassMaster, PersonPsychopath, Flash12, trumpeter, ThisIsASentence, axue, Linnyflower, hodori01, Cube1, Christopher03151, LLJ, Einsteinhead, monkeyl, Dot22, to_chicken, katmcphie, Kwow, ShineBunny, DeathLlama9, bigmath, AC2014, Cardinals2014, ingenio, oceanair, richy, tiger528, gamjawon, champion999, nihao4112, popsiclebirdiepotato, mingxu, WarriorSon, skonar, ah123, sw993, SuperRaeNXZ, eveningstarandlion, MathArt4, Carrots101, hy2015, dantx5, W.Sun, mathwhiz16, relay400, Temp456, ishankhare, soreu7, Altamira140, hiabc, EpicSkills32, pandabear10, NTA1907, kingwrecker, glory_of_math, rlybd5, I-_-I, claserken, love_emojis, Kid_025, Parametrics, popcorn1, fifty51, XanderJ, TheDarkPrince, mathcrazymj, skipiano, pi-3.14, Mathguy5837, uptownmath, WIStanford2004, geoman523, The_Herring, SPG2500, Sun13, MathDroid69, Henry12345, blacksheep2003, premchandj, reun, kndhan, jobob92, soojoong, IceParrot, firetiger84, GeneralCobra19, hockey10, TH.Attract, TropicalDog, akondepudi, AMC_Kid, Juno, TheMagician, Mathisfun04, birdinglulu, g1zq, ballislife21, moab33, MATHCOUNTS_Foundation, Zoombini, Woolly_Mammoth, mathchess5, sophie8, LadiesMan217, cosinechicken, azduncan, ar07jog, Blue_Whale, DuoQuinQuagintillion, shreyasb, thkim1011, AmazingMonkey, Samchooo, IvantheKingIII, wx_family, GoodApple8888, Marzi, PiAreSquared, KYang, gymnast19, gogiants, psa, Archimedes15, asp211, adihaya, thedoge, bensonduck, Gluncho, aaronliu, avn, pianoman24, TideBleach, jack74, AFK16, Iamawesome1, speulers_theorem, MIRB16, SpaceHead1AU, Groot, Th3Numb3rThr33, Ultroid999OCPN, mathathlete06, ilovenumbers, batta, Ashford, Sotowa, gimbob, FairyTailLover, eisirrational, luckylw, DaedalusMind, beastgert, tauros, Fourth_Dimension, ccx09, BBBBMMMMLLLLE, k2005, mgrimalo, Max0815, BibbityBop, cuphead_ftw, whatRthose, geekiness, green_dog_7983, GreenSilverHawk13, ElectroVortex, techguy2, dacammel, fibonacci11101, natiecswim, Math-Ninja, chocolatelover111, dogsareawesome123, coolak, Barry.B.Benson, ajmalla, Sherlock2018, creeperhissboom, Thothdragonfly2, potato36, TheEvaluator, foxtrot3, avaaops, Mathnerd1223334444, j3370, integrated_JRC, dragon78, Kbwuf, ironpanther29, alligator1234, harry1234, Amir Hossein, ShivaS, Carpemath, mathleticguyyy, Krypton36, Alex0721, IonelP, RYang2, blitzkrieg21, UnevenRocket, skywalker321, haha0201, nsd08, solver1104, lkarhat, nckim, fry8, Oo0f, MaThSzzzzzz, asdf334, Lcz, SlimTune, mathapple101, FIREDRAGONMATH16, asterix_1, Colball, milktae., riben, Bacon2387, jjmath123, steven2015, Toinfinity, Grizzy, usernameyourself, celtictiger, Mistyketchum28, jetpakturtle, genius21C, vedonidesimath, geolord1316, MistakeCorrectionBot, spiderman_f, aie8920, OlympusHero, BananaMan292749, rf20008, Hippoman, lakecomo224, 516260, Sebee, taranw, aa1024, MathJams, anc3, coolkid77, crazydog, mathNart, herobrine-india, Shark0wl, herbs_li, hdrcure, OronSH, Bluejay24, GrantStar, Flying_Bird, middletonkids, cubical, SciBoy2000, simonicorn, Mathematician3399, MDZELE5, awesomeming327., DSL13, SBose, fundamentals, asotahotmail.com, peace09, RohanQV, dolphinday, ATGY, NamePending, smartatmath, math_3210, JD12, zhanglulinca, WisePenguin, PM.MATHLEAGUE.VA.CHAMP, ksdicecream, MathWizard237, alexdillonchen, suvamkonar, Kmath1234, Pi-rate, ARay10, BakedPotato66, CoolCarsOnTheRun, happyhippos, Zhaom, mrmath0720, wamofan, hamburgerwhizz, super.shamik, ObjectZ, DuoDuoling0, poplintos, LightningGirl, Math626, aaja3427, justJen, justin6688, mathking999, nicarmt, HIA2020, vinnakota2010, captainnobody, csong, smarty101, Blueclay, amazingxin777, bsatvik, Jc426, blinketh, mobro, rushingriver, math_squared, lc426, gecko1234, SigmaPiE, DramaticFlossKid, mathisverynice, Forever-Math, Math_olympics, JD9, pog, Possible, rayfish, tenebrine, ilovepizza2020, riverblossom, QQMath, lordofeverything, kavya.rajesh, Jndd, beep123, Rose6767, hi.., etvat, ImSh95, bestzack66, Learner243, ostriches88, lovefractions, Eagle23, Eat314, samrocksnature, AoPS_0829, flutterpuppy, Lavendertail, ihatemath123, ivyshine13, MERC12345, cryptographer, aops-g5-gethsemanea2, colts1964, VKU427, MathLion11, brendan_cape, Geometry285, Bradygho, Spicysaurus, a.shyam.25, Brendangho, Boss97, I_guess_Tanmay_Natani, su4532, FaThEr-SqUiRrEl, Sedro, mich7math, exp-ipi-1, bsu1, SparklyFlowers, mathcounts7373, son7, HWenslawski, Pusheen25, IdkHowToAddNumbers, HamstPan38825, boing123, Testking, TryhardMathlete, Pi31, EmeraldNarwhal, SmartGroot, megarnie, pi271828, jhu08, violin21, Equinox8, thin21, tricky.math.spider.gold.1, andyloo666, dragonborn56, kante314, stevenschen, evanhliu2009, Robomania_534, dneary, BelieverofMaths, ehz2701, Technodoggo, G8L18M, adriancheung, FalconMaster, hh99754539, alex_ban, ANAIYER, Nickelslordm, akliu, DofL, JerryLau-40430, rainbow2011, emma_xie, zzethld, RedFlame2112, shadow09, MathNinja234, soggydollar, fluff_E, NTfish, megahertz13, dbnl, the_mathmagician, sehgalsh, J55406, Cygnet, TaskOverlap, loafofbread, asimov, Critical, TsunamiStorm08, Coco7, aidan0626, tangerine10, Peregrine11, challengeitmath, ryanbear, PatTheKing806, GeoWhiz4536, peelybonehead, Emily_Wang, mahaler, A_Crabby_Crab, MrThinker, Ansh2020, ap246, michaelwenquan, akpi2, elizhang101412, Dingdang2000, EthanHL, jmiao, Everestbaker, SpeedCuber7, Cokevending56, Ace9999, mathmax12, tigershark123, EpicBird08, nikola_tesla-roadster, alan9535, FourthRootOfX, zhenghua, ultimate_life_form, CrystalFlower, feliciaxu, thumper12, dr.3800, lpieleanu, tennistiger29, rg_ryse, ESAOPS, fortsferry, skronkmonster, ChuMath, jf123456, a_smart_alecks, meduh6849, Shadow_Sniper, HighWater, Lamboreghini, Adventure10, ujulee, WiseTigerJ1, Spiritpalm, tennisbeast14, stardog157, Solocraftsolo, gyaat, MathematicalGymnast573, rty, RhinocerosHornbill, inteligente, c_double_sharp, Blue_banana4, Exponent11, captainmath99, Kawhi2, sadas123, evt917, ahxun2006, 1218865, avyaank, giratina3, CXNJ.AoPS, mithu542, DreamineYT, Astonish, PhoenixDragon324
f (Reminder: Do not post Alcumus or class homework questions on this forum. Instructions below.) f
Welcome to the Middle School Math Forum! Please take a moment to familiarize yourself with the rules.
Overview:
Here are links to more detailed versions of the rules. These are from the older forums, so you can overlook "Classroom math/Competition math only" instructions.
Posting Guidelines
Update on Basic Forum Rules
What belongs on this forum?
How do I write a thorough solution?
How do I get a problem on the contest page?
How do I study for mathcounts?
Mathcounts FAQ and resources
Mathcounts and how to learn
As always, if you have any questions, you can PM me or any of the other Middle School Moderators. Once again, if you see spam, it would help a lot if you filed a report instead of responding
Marathons!
Relays might be a better way to describe it, but these threads definitely go the distance! One person starts off by posting a problem, and the next person comes up with a solution and a new problem for another user to solve. Here's some of the frequently active marathons running in this forum: Some of these haven't received attention in a while, but these are the main ones for their respective subjects. Rather than starting a new marathon, please give the existing ones a shot first.
You can also view marathons via the Marathon tag.
Think this list is incomplete or needs changes? Let the mods know and we'll take a look.
Welcome to the Middle School Math Forum! Please take a moment to familiarize yourself with the rules.
Overview:
- When you're posting a new topic with a math problem, give the topic a detailed title that includes the subject of the problem (not just "easy problem" or "nice problem")
- Stay on topic and be courteous.
- Hide solutions!
- If you see an inappropriate post in this forum, simply report the post and a moderator will deal with it. Don't make your own post telling people they're not following the rules - that usually just makes the issue worse.
- When you post a question that you need help solving, post what you've attempted so far and not just the question. We are here to learn from each other, not to do your homework.
- Avoid making posts just to thank someone - you can use the upvote function instead
- Don't make a new reply just to repeat yourself or comment on the quality of others' posts; instead, post when you have a new insight or question. You can also edit your post if it's the most recent and you want to add more information.
- Avoid bumping old posts.
- Use GameBot to post alcumus questions.
- If you need general MATHCOUNTS/math competition advice, check out the threads below.
- Don't post other users' real names.
- Advertisements are not allowed. You can advertise your forum on your profile with a link, on your blog, and on user-created forums that permit forum advertisements.
Here are links to more detailed versions of the rules. These are from the older forums, so you can overlook "Classroom math/Competition math only" instructions.
Posting Guidelines
Update on Basic Forum Rules
What belongs on this forum?
How do I write a thorough solution?
How do I get a problem on the contest page?
How do I study for mathcounts?
Mathcounts FAQ and resources
Mathcounts and how to learn
As always, if you have any questions, you can PM me or any of the other Middle School Moderators. Once again, if you see spam, it would help a lot if you filed a report instead of responding
Marathons!
Relays might be a better way to describe it, but these threads definitely go the distance! One person starts off by posting a problem, and the next person comes up with a solution and a new problem for another user to solve. Here's some of the frequently active marathons running in this forum: Some of these haven't received attention in a while, but these are the main ones for their respective subjects. Rather than starting a new marathon, please give the existing ones a shot first.
You can also view marathons via the Marathon tag.
Think this list is incomplete or needs changes? Let the mods know and we'll take a look.
This post has been edited 19 times. Last edited by jwelsh, Mar 21, 2020, 5:28 PM
Reason: update
Reason: update
